Guy Li as a Harem Protagonist?

I've been thinking; What would you guys think about Guy being the 'Harem Protagonist' of A Certain Alternate Universe. This is a scenario of course. Or is it not?

Well this turnout is as much a surprise to me as I'm sure it is to most of you!

Guy Li wrote:Well this turnout is as much a surprise to me as I'm sure it is to most of you!

No, actually I totally expected this result and it's mainly why I launched this poll in the first place, haha. I'll let you safely guess for which option I voted for.

Was there ever a point of genderbending Touma? In the end it simply shifted the object of harem from Touma to Guy. It goes without saying I'm opposed to the idea of keeping Touko and would like to unbend the Touma seeing as this is proof enough that regardless of genderbending Touma it didn't stop people from hopping from one harem object to the next potential candidate.

At least with Touma back on board it wouldn't feel as awkward or strange when interacting with the Kamijou brat.

I think that the idea of Touko is a bit strange in that it departs from the cannon verse, now I’m not saying everything has to be cannon but I think that the idea of gender bending a character is a bit strange. In perspective of Guy being a harem protagonist, i say that this mostly made me laugh and I don’t think that it is an entirely serious topic.

Touma was originally genderbent to Touko mainly because our previous admin (who has now left us) wanted to play a female character. I believe she also wanted to break away from the harem context. We had been looking into ways to re-introduce Touma, and we had some interesting ideas (that do not conflict with the rp story so far) which we are thinking of playing out later on in the rp.
Whether Guy becomes the new harem protagonist... I don't mind at all XD But if we're going to re-introduce Touma, we'll have to balance it out

Index wrote:Was there ever a point of genderbending Touma? In the end it simply shifted the object of harem from Touma to Guy. It goes without saying I'm opposed to the idea of keeping Touko and would like to unbend the Touma seeing as this is proof enough that regardless of genderbending Touma it didn't stop people from hopping from one harem object to the next potential candidate.

It seems that way, doesn't it? As I've said in the past, though I understand the intention behind the idea I never really agreed with it, mainly because I'm actually sort of fond of Touma as a protagonist. In any case now that our old admin has passed control over to me we will be seeing Touma in the future thanks to plot hijinks, so never fear. I think a much more elegant solution to the problem of Touma stealing the limelight is to keep him as an NPC for special plot events where he's needed.

As flattering as the harem protag thing, I always felt that it would be unfair on the other players to have one character receive all the attention. I'd rather split the harem up for the sake of diversity. Besides, Guy already has his hands full with the 'harem' he's got now.

Well As long as Guy doesn't try and take The NPC known as Takuto's little sister into his Harem I'm good.

Well, this poll isn't meant to be taken seriously anyway, cause shipping wars. I was just curious about how many people would agree to it in a what-if scenario.

And well, the attractive thing I found about harems is the interactions the protagonist has with the different girls, not really any couple itself (leaving my tsundere fetish aside of course). And Guy has quite the worthwhile (and hilarious) reactions, setting him with a single character would be quite the shame.